Consign & Sell

At One More Time, we offer cash/credit or consignment and we are always accepting clothing and accessories that follow our guidelines. Please bring your items to our "Check-In" counter and we will sort your items in a timely manner.

What We Take

Women's (Sizes 0 - 5XL)

  • Casual & Business Casual
  • Athletic Wear
  • Footwear & Accessories

Sorry, no wedding, formal or business professional.

Men's (Sizes S - 3XL)

  • Casual & Athletic
  • Footwear & Accessories

Sorry, no suits or sports jackets.

Seasons

SPRINGFebruary – April
SUMMERApril – Mid June
FALLAugust – October
WINTERSeptember – Mid-December

Authentic Items

Items go through a specific authentication process via Street Luxe, Entrupy, and Authenticate First.

Our Favorite Brands

J. Crew, Lululemon, Nike, Ann Taylor, Tory Burch, Tommy Bahama, Lane Bryant, Torrid, Michael Kors, Talbots, Kate Spade, Ralph Lauren, and many more!

Our Guidelines

  • Items must be purchased new within the last 3-4 years and currently in style.
  • Items must be on hangers or folded nicely in a basket or bag.
  • Must be freshly cleaned, free of pet hair, stains, or tears.

Consignment

Receive 1/2 of the selling price. Items stay in-store for 60 days with two scheduled markdowns.

Buy Outright (BOR)

Receive a cash offer (10-20% of retail) OR double that amount in non-expiring store credit.

Store Hours

Tue - Sat: 10 AM – 6 PM
Sun & Mon: CLOSED

Visit Us

1521 W 5th Avenue
Columbus, OH 43212

Contact

614.486.0031
chris@onemoretime.com

Disclaimer: Our inventory is sold "as-is", final sale, no returns.
Copyright © 2026 One More Time Family